Keylime Cheesecake

I meant to post this sometime in January, but I’ve missed that deadline now. Regardless, making this dessert was a good expiriment and one I plan to do again in the future.
I made this at Thanksgiving as an experiment. It turned out pretty well, and I plan on making it again at some point, but Thanksgiving and Christmas are too close together for this much cheesecake.

First…I didn’t make up either of the recipes I based this on, and I used them as they were and modified just a few things.

I used, the standard Philly Cheesecake recipe, and the Nelly and Joe’s key lime pie recipe. And then I just made some modificiations.

For the crust, I made a double batch and added the zest of one lime, but then only used 2/3rds of the total. I needed a thicker crust than the cheesecake called for to support all the weight, but not double the amount of crust, that would have been too much.

After I got the crust tamped down, baked off, and cooled, I whipped up the filling as per the directions and added 2 ounces of Nellie and Joe’s key lime juice to that, and got it into a 350 oven instead of the recipe listed 325.

While the cheesecake was baking, I mixed up the Key Lime pie filling.

At 40 minutes into the bake time, I opened the oven and gently, oh so very very gently, poured the key lime filling on top of the cheesecake and spread it all the way out to the edges. The goal here is to disturb the cheesecake part as little as possible so you get two distinct layers, and the cake tastes different depending on where in the piece your is taken from. For the most part, I achieved this.

Cook the entire thing for another 20 minutes, and take out to cool until you can place into the fridge for 4 hours. I did my cake on Wednesday night for the Thursday dinner because I wanted it to have plenty of time to set up.

For topping I used the 2 ingredient no machine ice cream recipe found here. But it only sat in the freezer for about 4 hours the first night before we used it, and that was my prefered texture for it. After that it was basically plain ice cream topping.

Plated Weeks 44-47 – This is the Final Plated Reviews Post

First, let me just say, we have quite liked our Plated experiment and would do it again in the future if we wanted to shake things up and be more experimental in the kitchen. We have chosen to be more budget conscious in light of a large purchase we’ve just made and that means things like Plated are being cut out for now. We may do it again in the future, but we may not, so this will be the last of these review type posts. Hopefully if you found these because you are considering trying plated, the collection of these posts will help you make that decision.

Week 44
Cajun Pork Dirty Rice with Bell Pepper and Scallion
This was tasty and easy to make. We both liked it. I could see doing it again and maybe putting it into a regular rotation.

Creamy Butternut Squash and Chicken Linguine with Parmesan Breadcrumbs

This was OK. The Butternut definitely added something different to the pasta dish but we probably won’t do this again on our own.

Week 45
Curried Cauliflower Soup with Crispy Chickpeas and Toasted Naan.

We both quite liked this one. It was a crappy day and the soup and naan were perfect. We’ll probably make this on our own on my next soup kick, but I’ll use regular coconut milk instead of lite. The soup needed a bit more body and I think that would do it.

Vietnamese Caramel Chicken with Roasted Chinese Broccoli and Basmati Rice

This was OK, but nothing stellar. This was the first time we had eaten Chinese Broccoli and it was good. If I saw it in the store, I’d pick some up to eat as a vegetable for other meals.

Week 46
Japanese Chicken Tsukune and Coconut Rice and Chinese Broccoli

These were really good but the sauce never thickened like the instructions indicated it would, which was a disappointment because it was tasty and it being thicker means it would have stuck to the meat and rice much better.

Piri Piri Chicken with Crispy Potato Chips and Sauteed Kale

Success! I only chose this dish so I could learn to make Peri Peri sauce on my own, so I consider it a win even though I don’t particularly care for bone in chicken thighs.

Week 47
Hoisin Beef Buns with Ginger-Sesame Slaw and Baked Sweet Potato Fries

So good! I want to do this again with different buns. The meat was savory and tasty and the Ginger-Sesame slaw was the perfect counterpoint. The sweet potato fries were meh, but the rest we’d totally do again.

Potato Latkes with Horseradish Sour Cream, Roasted Carrots, and Spinach Salad

The salad was lacking and I’d have liked to have seen more seasoning and such in the latkes, but they were still crispy and good and I learned things making them. And the horseradish, chive, sour cream sauce was definitely something I’ll start making for other dishes.

Plated Weeks 40-43

Week 40
Butternut Squash and Poblano Enfrijoladas with Queso Fresco
I don’t remember this one. At. All. And I’m the one who cooked it. But shmoo does and he says he remembers liking it.

Seared Steak with Ginger-Roasted Tomatoes, Butternut Squash, and Cardamom-Lime Yogurt
I also don’t really remember this one. I vaguely remember the ginger tomato saucy bit but mostly, not really. Which I guess means it didn’t suck.

Week 41
Cashew Chicken with Bok Choy and Garlic Rice
This was ok but nothing spectacular. Sort of a typical vaguely asian-esque dish. I would have liked it to be more specific and maybe have more flavor. The garlic rice was decent though.

Beef Moussaka-Stuffed Delicata Squash with Greek Yogurt Sauce
This was different and pretty good! We’d eat it again, and I’d maybe consider

Week 42
Spicy Chicken Arrabbiata with Parmesian-Roasted Cauliflower
This was good but….. the instructions had you skillet fry the chicken skin down to get a crispy skin, but then it has you cook it in the sauce in the oven which makes the crispy skin you made that special effort for all soggy.

Chana Masala with Shallot Pakoras and Basmati Rice
Shmoo really liked this one. The shallots were battered in a chick pea flour that I thought could use a bit more seasoning but shmoo just loved. It was like fancy onion rings with an extra crispy crust. I’d consider doing this one again if he asked for it.

Week 43
Chicken Paprikash and Bell Pepper and Egg Noodles
This was good but had the same chicken skin fry and then cook in sauce so it’s not as crispy thing going on. But otherwise, quite tasty.

Butternut Squash Empanadas with Mozzarella, Salsa Roja, and Spinach Salad
This was good and we’d totally do it again. We both really enjoyed the squash as a filling and how well it went with the “salsa roja” which, I’ve mentioned last time we had empanandas with salsa roja from plated… isn’t saucey enough to be called salsa anything. It’s just cooked tomatoes to pile on top mostly. But still, tasty!

Plated Weeks 36-39

Week 36
Curried Lamb Tacos with Cabbage Slaw and Cilantro-Lime Yogurt
Good but as far as tacos go, we’ve had better. I did like that the lamb was seasoned with vindaloo seasonings but I didn’t like the tortillas they sent or the “slaw”. Yes, those are ironic quotation marks. If the slaw had been more tangy and the yogurt sauce less runny, it probably would have been a great dish.

Grilled Summer Vegetable Panzanella with Ricotta Salata

Fair to middling on this one. All the veggies in it were grilled and that was a nice break for me since it means shmoo had to do the cooking part, but I don’t remember it as amazing either.

Week 37
Lamb Gözleme with Roasted Carrots and Herbed Yogurt Sauce
The carrot side for this dish was just stupid. They’d have been better cut up and baked in the gözleme, which is basically just an empanada using two pieces of dough. Otherwise tasty, would make again if I had the ingredients on hand, but since it’s lamb, I probably won’t.

Japanese Cabbage Salad with Shichimi Togarashi Chickepeas and Miso Vinaigrette
We ate it, it was ok. I like miso paste, and the seasoned chickpeas were alright. I have it rated as a straight middle of the road recipe. Nothing wrong with it, but we didn’t LIKE it.

Week 38
Kale and Red Rice Salad with Roasted Sweet Potato, Goat Cheese, and Candied Walnuts
I did not love this one but I seem to remember that shmoo did for some reason. Not that it was bad at all, it just wasn’t particularly up my alley either, though we did leave out the mushrooms because they had gone bad. I felt like this dish used too many dishes. There was baking and boiling and sauce making and candied walnut making…. ALL THE THINGS! I get to do the clean-up also for these so I was not enamored. This dish used too many dishes not to be AMAZING. And it wasn’t, so pbbbbbbt.

Spicy Sambal Pork Stir-Fry with Bok Choy and Cashews
Tasty! Probably not something we will seek to make again, but if we did, we’d probably not tweak it a bunch, as it was fine as is.

Week 39
Chop Steak with Crispy Brussels Sprout Home Fries and Herb Compound Butter
This was a damn tragedy. The ingredients were so good and could have been amazing all together if done properly, but alas, they were not. I had high expectations on this one and with each step of the recipe I kept telling myself, “okayyyyy, trust them, they are the professionals” but no. I should not have trusted. The recipe has you put the garlic in the compound butter, and a tablespoon of shallots as well. The herbs used were flat parsley and tarragon. I think the garlic and half the shallots would have been far better served being put into the chop steak, and then maybe add some thyme into the herb mix for the butter, with a tiny bit of salt. (Then maybe when all the butter melted on the steak you wouldn’t be left with chucks of raw minced garlic all over the top of the meat. I like garlic, even when raw, but this was just too much.) Having sugar at all for the hash was just out of place, if they really wanted that mustard on it, it should have been more than what was supplied, and honestly the seedy mustard, while tasty, didn’t really go with the compound butter, so why they had you use both together on the hash at the end is something I can’t even guess. Usually plated is so good about things I think are iffy and don’t want to follow instructions on, but this dish was not. Shmoo and I were both disappointed and did not finish.

Italian Sausage Soup with Caramelized Fennel and Ditalini
We both liked this. It was a good soup, and it happened to be a cooler rainy day when I cooked it, and it was perfect for the evening. I am a sucker for good soups and I could see doing this again with my own spin on it, but even if I don’t, I’ll certainly use fennel again in other soups at some point.

Plated Weeks 31-35

Week 31

Crispy Tilapia with Gazpacho Sauce and Summer Salad
I don’t like fish but as far as fish go, I’d eat this one again. Possibly even up to once a month. I wouldn’t LOVE it, but I’d eat it. The Gazpacho sauce I ended up doctoring a bit with some garlic and red wine vinegar and green hot sauce because it was so bland, but over all a decent dish.

Farfalle with Brocoli and Italian Sausage
This was good but very similar to the Orrechette dish we’ve made several times since we first had it. I liked the change up of broccoli for the peas, and the different noodle shape, but very similar dish. So good, but we figured that it was going in.

Week 32

Pork Meatball Bahn Mi with Shallow Jam and Sriracha Mayo
This was good but not AMAZING like I was hoping it would be. We came away thinking it was a good sandwich but that’s about it. I didn’t feel like I had learned how to make a proper Bahn Mi from this and I already knew how to make a meatball sandwich.

Grilled Vegetable Gyros with Yogurt Feta Sauce
We picked this because it was all grilled Veg, and while it was not suck, it’s not really something we’d seek to make again. Yogurt Feta sauce is no substitute for an actual tzatkiki. I’d have preferred a yogurt sauce with herbs and have the feta crumbled on the veggies at the end. Also, mushrooms, so that was a stike against it for me anyway. I keep trying, but I keep not liking them.

Week 33

Jerk Chicken with Coconut Rice and Summer Vegetables
We liked this. They had you cook the rice in coconut milk and that helped give it some flavor and added creaminess. I still don’t care for whatever rice it is they use, as it always cooks up oddly but the coconut milk trick is something I could see using next time I do us up a green curry. The Jerk seasoning was a premade mix, so no thoughts on it really other than it tasted like Jerk seasoning.

Chicken Shawarma Salad with Lemon-Honey Dressing and Creamy Tahini
OK so, not shawrma in my opinion. at. all. But! The Tahini sauce was nice. Basically this was a Middle Eastern flavored salad, and it was good, but not amazing, that tahini though…

Week 34

Hoisin Pork Tacos with Miso Corn and Cabbage Cilantro Slaw
This was good. I think the flavors could have been a little stronger in the meat and corn but over all tasty. Shmoo’s coworkers really REALLY liked this one and made it a day or two before us, so our expectations were pretty high. We were not as impressed, but it was good.

Gnocchi Pomodoro with Summer Squash, Basil, and Fresh Mozzarella
Shmoo really liked this but I figured he would because he likes gnocchi quite a bit. This had flavor and was good. It’s not going to be a go to recipe for us, but I could see making it again once squash is back in season next year because shmoo loved it.

Week 35

Pork Egg Rolls with Crunch Slaw and Sweet and Sour Duck Sauce
This was pretty good. We were shorted one egg roll wrapper so there was extra filling and I didn’t bother to report that so I can’t tell you how customer service would have handled it. I liked this recipe because I learned to make duck sauce, and they were pretty good egg rolls. I would have liked to maybe have seen the cabbage slaw in the egg roll as well and not on the side though.

Lamb Shakshuka with Parsley Rice and Pistachios
This is our second Shakshuka from plated, but different than the first because of the lamb and pistachios. Also the starch for this one was the rice and not pita breads. Otherwise it was basically the same. Plated did their normal deal with lamb so what you get is a mix of ground beef and lamb that you cook up loosely, but it added a different flavor to the dish and the pistachios were an interesting texture in the rice. Personally, I’ve been doing a variation on this with stew beef instead of ground, but I like the idea of adding some nuts to the rice for flavor and texture.

Plated week 30

Chicken Samosas with Cucumber Raita Salad

This was tasty. Well, the Samosas were tasty. But I also kinda of cheated on them. The Tikka Masala curry paste did not turn the ground chicken as red as it appeared in the example photo on the recipe card, and it tasted a bit bland, so I threw in a rough tablespoon’s worth of Tandoori seasoning to help that out. The recipe used empanada dough for the samosas, then they were fried up on the stove top. As for the raita salad, eh, we weren’t fans. It wasn’t seasoned well and the consistancy was weird. The yogurt they sent was low fat so when that bit of dairy was combined with the lemon juice, it just didn’t blend up well enough in my opinion. The yogurt was already super runny and since citrus curdles dairy, just eh. Also, it just didn’t taste as good as a cucumber relish/sauce I’ve been making for a while now for us anyway, so we were comparing it to that when we ate, and it came up lacking. Shmoo doesn’t care for cucumbers generally, he eats them, but doesn’t seek them out. He recently read (on reddit maybe?) what he feels is the reason he doesn’t like them: The best part of the cucumber tastes like the worst part of a watermelon (the rind). He agrees with that statement whole heartedly. We’d probably do the samosas again with strong seasoning, like vindaloo, and do the cucumber salad the way I normally do it when we are having tacos.

Lamb Meatballs with Israeli Salad and Toasted Pita

This was pretty good, however it wasn’t as good as the Lamb Kabab dish a few weeks ago, so it’s not something we’d make, we’d just have that dish instead, because it’s very similar. The green tahini sauce wasn’t as good as the mint sauce in the other dish, but I could see using it. This was the best version of an Israeli Salad they’ve sent instructions for, and I liked it, though I think I should have put a tidge more salt in the dressing, or maybe some kalamata olives in the salad. The dressing had sumac in it, which added a tiny bit of texture and flavor that was different, so I’ll probably use that again in a future vinagrette whip up on my own since I have a little jar in the cabinet and we never really use it. The instructions for this dish also had you tear up the pita for serving, no idea why, it just made it a pain in the ass to eat. Oh and the instructions had you bake the meatballs, but I didn’t, I just stuck them in a pan and cooked them til done through and a little crusted on each side, because it’s too damn hot to be heating up the whole house with the oven when I just use the stop top more quickly instead and everything cools off faster.

Plated week 29

Spanakopita Grilled Cheese Sandwiches with Greek Salad
We liked this one, mostly. The grilled cheese was good but shmoo didn’t really care for the “salad” which I found yummy. This one wasn’t as good at fig preserve one, but I definitely see fancy grilled cheeses in our future for dinner.

Vietnamese Pork Bún with Peanut Hoisin Sauce
This was a lot like the vietnamese shaking beef from a few weeks back, glass noodles (aka bean thread noodles) and all. But it was with pork instead of beef, and instead of having you mix everything up before serving it as a noodle salad, it’s all done seperately so you had to work a little harder to get a complete bite. The highlight of the dish was the peanutbutter hoisin sauce. I think I’ll make some of that next time we do the shaking beef, and then we’ll pass on doing this one ourselves.

Plated Catchup 2, Weeks 18-28

Between this post and the last one, we are now all caught up and hopefully the weekly posts will pick up again on a more regular basis.

Week 18

Cuban Beef Bowls with Mojo Sauce and Avocado Pineapple Salsa
Not a bad dish. We would have used a different rice. The Avocado Pineapple salsa was VERY DIFFERENT. Not bad per se, just, VERY DIFFERENT.

Tandoori Chicken with Yogurt-Roasted Cauliflower and Cilantro Mint Chutney

This was a bit of a disappointment because the tandoori was the spices not the cooking style, and I had chosen this to maybe learn more about Indian cooking styles. Throwing chicken in a pan with some sauce is something I can already do. The yogurt mix on the cauliflower was messy to do, and the cauliflower ended up being oddly textured. Flavor wise it was just lacking.

Week 19

Fish Tacos with Avocado Sauce and Crunchy Slaw

Shmoo really liked these, in fact he finished mine for me. I didn’t dislike this dish, I just don’t like fish. But the tilapia was not offensive in general as far as fish goes, and I ate more of these than I did the Teriyaki Salmons a few weeks back.

Balsamic Steak Sandwiches with Creamy Horseradish
This was ok. We weren’t impressed, but it wasn’t bad. The balsamic didn’t really stand out as a flavor and the horseradish was weak.

Week 20

Savory Gruyere Bread Pudding with Spring Vegetables
This was a miss for both of us. It’s just not our flavors I guess and the texture needed some help also. I really wanted to come out of this with a decent understanding of savory bread puddings, but mostly I just think no, it’s not a thing now.

Cuban Beef Piccadillo with Spinach Rice
We liked this. We’ve made it twice since. Mostly because it’s easy and the basic ingredients were things we had on hand. It’s like Italian style sloppy joe on rice. Easy, filling, done.

Week 21

Southwestern Stuffed Peppers with Avocado Arugula Salad
The salad was better than the peppers. Shmoo loves stuffed peppers and he was disappointed with this. I tolerate them and found it lacking over all. The salad was decent, but we aren’t huge quinoa fans, and the flavor was just lacking.

Grilled Chicken Caesar Pizza with Shaved Parmesan
This was really good, but it was SO MESSY. We got it because it was a grilled dough and we’d never done that before. But it was a lot of work for a pizza. I spent a lot of kitchen despite him being the one “cooking” the chicken and pizza dough. We came nowhere close to finishing this meal. There was just too much food.

Week 22

Vietnamese Shaking Beef over Glass Noodles

We both really liked this. It was a pain in the ass to eat because the noodles were so long, and things just didn’t incorporate very well but the flavors were awesome. I just remade it with different noodles (Thai vermicelli) and we decided the glass noodles were a better choice after all so we won’t be subbing those going forward.

Falafel Spiced Chickpeas with Eggplant, Naan, and Israeli Salad
It was messy because of all the toppings on the pita, and we have determined we don’t really like eggplant; we should probably stop trying. The toasted chick peas were awesome. Tasty and crunchy.

Week 23

Coconut Curry-Crusted Cod with Jasmine Rice
It wasn’t awful but it wasn’t really great either. I was disappointed in what they called a “crust”, because the whole fished is not crusted, it’s just some stuff on the top. The rice had carrots, peas, and spinach in it and still managed to be bland.

Fontina and Brie Grilled Cheese with Fig Compote and Frisée Salad
This was great. We both loved it. Well, not the frisée salad, that was a waste of an ingredient. But the grilled cheese itself, super tasty. The fig compote was both in the sandwich and on the side, and while I personally think a longer cooking time for that would have made it better and more compote/preserve like in the more traditional sense, it was still super tasty. We are planning to do this again but it’s going to take finding the right bread to do it on. One thing I learned from this one however, was using mayonnaise on the outside of the bread instead of butter for better browning. It wasn’t bad, but I’m a butter girl, so when we do this for ourselves it will likely be with butter.

Week 24

Greek Horiatiki with Marinated Feta, Za’atar Naan, and Toasted Chickpeas
I liked the salad that came out of this, but mostly it was like the Falafel dish from week 23 but without the eggplant. So we liked it, but it was not AMAZING.

Homemade Breakfast Sausage with Asparagus Hash and Sunny-Side Up Eggs
We liked this. I learned that breakfast sausage is just ground pork with breakfast sausage herbs in it. I know that sounds obvious, but I mean, really, that’s it. I feel like could easily make my own now in the future and will no longer seek out a special kind of sausage for a recipe, instead I will just get plain ground pork and season accordingly .

Week 25

Provençal Zucchini and Potato Gratin and Butter Lettuce Salad

This was… not that great. I really wanted to like it, but it needed more seasoning or stronger flavors over all. Aaaaaand the butter lettuce. It was so gritty. I mean, GRITTY. I had soaked it for 20 minutes head of time, then swished it and rinsed it thoroughly and then put it in the salad spinner and it was still gritty as hell.

Lamb Kebabs with Papas Bravas and Mint Chimichurri
So damn good. The lamb was mixed with beef to keep it from being too overwhelmingly lamby, and the Chimichurri was perfect amount of mint. One change we had to make was not putting the almonds in the kebabs, but there was extra red onion so I put those in for that little bit of texture instead. We recently remade this dish , exactly the same way, I just added a few more things to the salad. We’ll definitely do this again.

Week 26

Coconut-Poached Chicken with Jasmine Rice and Crispy Shallots
The shallot was bad. I ended up replacing it with some dried shallots I had in the cabinet, so not as good as it could have been because they had to be rehydrated and then fried, so that was odd. Plated did give us a credit for the bad shallot though, so there’s that. This was ok, but it could have used some heat. Curry or a pepper or something. The Thai chili that was in it was not very present. This dish was OK, but it’s not one I’m looking to remake.

Grilled Steak with Potato Salad and Charred Zucchini
Who doesn’t like grilled steak? Same with the zucchini. The potato salad was done differently than I’d ever done it before, so I learned a new method from it but it’s not my preferred way to do potato salad. (The instructions had you mix all the wet in a bowl and then put your potatoes in it and coat them, so it had a lot more sauce than my family based recipe). I’ve done the potato salad again this one once since, because this method really lends itself to smaller one meal amounts of potato salad where as my traditional family recipe does not.

Week 27

Peruvian-Style Grilled Chicken with Avocado Salad and Ají Verde
The grilled avocado was surprisingly good. The aji sauce was very fresh tasting, and it was a pretty good salad over all.

Buffalo Chicken Meatball Sliders with Carrot Fries and Greek Yogurt Ranch
Thanks to a co-worker of shmoo’s also doing plated, we knew the buffalo sliders were going to need some help in the spicy department. We provided that help. I used double the sriracha in the ground chicken mixture, and then added our own buffalo sauce from the fridge. Carrot fries are weird. We didn’t hate them, but I am not going to make them again.

Week 28

Korean Steak Tacos with Kimchi

We liked this. It was very flavorful. I did not cut the meat against the grain like I should have because of the way the filets were sent to us, and that made it a little chewy to eat, but otherwise, all good. The butter lettuce in this one was not gritty and there was so much of it, we had a huge salad a few days later.

Chicken Bruschetta with Balsamic and Shaved Parmesan
This was good though nothing like we expected. I wanted to try this because I wanted to see how someone else made bruschetta. It involved way more cooking than I would have thought was necessary. Cooking the tomatoes and onions made them a lot sweeter than what I would consider a traditional bruschetta flavor to be. The balsamic glaze was pre-made and you just squeezed it over everything. It was flavorful, but again a bit sweeter than I would have expected. We’ll continue to make bruschetta in the future, but probably not this way.

Plated Catchup, Weeks 11-17

Week 11

Beef Rendang with Lemongrass, Kaffir Lime, and Yellow Rice
We liked it, but it was not an inspirational recipe for us. I was not compelled to recraft it or recreate it in any way, but we don’t regret getting it either.

Brown Butter Orecchiette
This was delicious and we’ve made it twice since. Shmoo LOVED it. “That stuff was fucking delicious, plus it had peas in it!!”

Week 12

Buffalo Cauliflower Bowl with Corn, Romaine, and Greek Yogurt Ranch
Tasty, and very likely something we’d do again if we could remember more often that we liked it. Filling though vegetarian.

Korean Beef Burritos with Kimchi Rice and Gochujang Aioli
Wasn’t very memorable. I do remember being disappointed that there was not actual Kimchi to go in the rice. (Looking back at the ingredient list for this recipe, it shows 1 cup of kimchi, but we didn’t get that and we didn’t notice that we didn’t, or it wasn’t true kimchi, because I distinctly remember being disappointed about there being no kimchi for this one, and shmoo remembers me saying something about it at the time.)

Week 13

Shakshuka with Roasted Eggplant, Bell Peppers, and Feta
We really liked the Shakshuka, but I did pick out most of my eggplant. The more vegetarian dishes we do, the more I just know I don’t like eggplant and don’t want to eat it. Shmoo will eat it but doesn’t really care for it either.
Other than that though, this was really good, and we will probably consider making it again with tofu or seitan (quorn, morningstar, etc) at some point.

Teriyaki Salmon Tacos with Seaweed Salad
The Teriyaki Salmon tacos were a hit with shmoo. The Seaweed Salad we both found repulsive. I ate 1.5 of my 3 tacos for this dish. Fish is always going to be work for me to eat, but I gave it an honest effort and learned that Teriyaki is a decent way to cover up fish taste, so there’s that.

Week 14

Risotto with Kale Walnut Pesto
This was not a true risotto or a true pesto and Dinosaur Kale is weird. Other than that, it was a tasty rice dish that had a good flavor overall, and the walnuts added some texture so it wasn’t boring to eat.

Caprese Empanadas
These were yum! I need to find a good empanada dough recipe so we can make them again ourselves. I always find things you eat with your hands appealing for some reason, so possibly that this was empanadas made me like it more than I would have it if were done in a slightly different preparation, but we liked these and would eat again.

Week 15

First, I need to talk about the Arugula and Plated’s customer Service for this one. Our Arugula was going bad or already there when we went to eat these on Saturday and Sunday night. (Our boxes come on Tuesdays, so it had been in our fridge for 4-5 days at this point.) The next week’s dish also had Arugula in it that was already starting to go, and I was cooking it Tuesday night, so I had shmoo contact customer service to let them know their Arugula was an issue and they should look into their supplier.

Customer service was very nice. She listened to the issue, and then she credited shmoo 24 bucks to his account for the bad Arugula. While that’s nice and all, and probably their policy, that really wasn’t what we were aiming for as a result. I didn’t really want money back or a credit, I wanted them to stop using shitty Arugula that was going bad in our boxes. I can generally tell when lettuces and such are about to go bad, I feel like most people can. Why was that packed in our boxes?

Anyway, can’t complain about the credit, it was over and above what we were seeking as a result. The only real complaint I have is that the rep closed out the chat session prior to shmoo doing so. Now, we were done and he was trying to figure out how to close it, but as someone who has worked customer service for years, and had to do chat support, you never never close your session first when you are the support rep, and if you do, it’s because something went wrong or they went unresponsive for X number of minutes where X > 5. So while no harm no foul, if I were this person’s manager, I wouldn’t like that behavior, and it irked me to see it as a customer. Shmoo however, had absolutely no problem with this.

Beef Bolognese Sliders with Ricotta and Arugula Salad
Huge disappointment. Liked the brioche buns and the Ricotta/Parm mixture on top and the carmelized onions in the meat, but either we just never realized Bolognese was so damn bland, or this was just too damn bland in general. The Ricotta and Parm mixturem, the onions in the meat, and the brioche buns, we carried over into some Sloppy Joes a week or two later, and that WAS good. So now this might be one of my go-to super fast meals as long as the sauce on the meat is Manwhich sauce and not bland bland bolognese. (The salad was meh due to the failing Arugula.)

Crunchy Chicken Milanese with Honey Mustard and Arugula
This was good, though I thought it used too many dishes. I’d do chicken again this way. The honey mustard was a nice addition as well. I could see making this version of honey mustard to go with some chicken tenders. I replaced the crappy Arugula with some some iceberg lettuce we had in the fridge for the salad, and it was still good, mostly because the vinaigrette was a very bright taste. If the Arugula had been better off, the salad likely would have been the star of the plate.

Week 16

Cacio e Pepe Gnocchi with Asparagus, Peas, and Mint
We both liked this one, though I think shmoo might have liked it just because he really likes gnocci. I’ve used the technique for this sauce with linguini on days I work from home for quick easy but tasty and filling lunch twice now, and know I will do so again.

Steak Gyros with Greek Yogurt-Feta Sauce and Peppers
This was OK, but this was the dish that the Arugula was already going bad on the same day we got the shipment, so over all it could have been better but it was good.

Week 17

Little Gem Caesar with Crispy Chickpeas, Purple Potatoes, and Spring Onion
This was both hit and miss.
Plated contacted us about substitutions in advance. Green gem lettuce instead of reg gem, and spring scallions instead of spring onions.
The seasoned and baked chickpeas and purple potatoes were really good.
The lettuce was halved and then quartered longways, and then used like that. I liked this but it also kinda made it difficult to eat. I could see doing this again but then also doing some crosswise cuts to make it more bite sized, so you still get the large block of lettuce, but not a whole spear at once.
The Ceasar dressing was not a Ceasar dressing and the whole reason I picked this recipe was to learn to make a proper Ceasar dressing.
The watermelon radish. We were sent WAY. TOO. MUCH. Saying too much is not even nearly the amount that was sent. It was also tough and not very flavorful. Regular radishes would have been really good here, but going to take a pass on watermelon radishes in the future.

Seared Steak Quesadillas with Poblano Salsa and Chimichurri
So so good. We are already making this again for ourselves because we have most of the ingredients on hand and skirt steak was on sale when we went to order groceries. Shmoo will grill the seasoned skirt steak, and then we’ll do this one night, and fajitas another. (Even later update, we’ve made this ourselves twice!)

Plated Week 10

This week was good. We enjoyed both dishes and I can see making our own versions of them at a later date.

Peanut Noodles with Bok Choy and Miso-Glazed Eggplant
This was tasty. Shmoo generally avoids miso, but was really happy with how it worked in this dish. I don’t think I’ve had a peanut-ginger flavored sauce before and I quite liked it, and the miso glaze on the eggplant helped it out quite a bit. The noodle sent was linguine again, which we still find odd for asian flavored dishes but for the most part I guess noodles are noodles. The egg plant did it’s job. It was the meat substitue of the dish, and that was fine. I would have honestly preferred some extra-firm tofu instead. Cubed and put in the miso-mirin glaze to marinate, possible overnight, would have been divine. Chicken would have also been good, but we both feel like the point of the vegetarian dishes is to be tasty and vegetarian, so we both sided on tofu as an eggplant replacement for this one.

Seared Steak with Bell Pepper Panzanella
Shmoo loves bell peppers so his statement about this one was “It was really good, I loved the panzanella and steak is always great!” This was the first time for both of us eating panzanella, and my first time eating an arugala based salad. I’ve been avoiding it ever since having an escarole salad a few years back that was supposed to be super tasty (shmoo did like it) but was way too bitter for me. Everyone says escarole is “spicy” but all I got was a mouth full of bitter. And I digress! Arugala was good. We’d do this one again for sure. I do think I’d do this as one dish though, instead of a salad and a meat I’d just put the meat in the dish (likely chicken that had been marinated in something, and then cubed about the same size as the bread) and call it done. When there are enough diverse flavors and textures in a dish, I don’t see much of a point in having the protein be on the side unless you really want a particular one, like say, steak, shrimp, lobster, etc.

We should have another desserts post soon, as shmoo is in the kitchen right now catching up on those.